Yes it would......but we ARE playing EQ,where logic doesn't always reign true.....does the Bag of the Tinkerers give Tinkering bonus? Don't think so..... But being a tool belt would be nice if it came with +% Trade-skill bonus of some sort...or a clickable effect to create special tools used in some recipes.....:-) Or better yet Weight Reduction for overall inventory/equipment LOL Wow!! Don't I like to dream!!??!! hehe :-)