I have an Oger zerker lvl 24 and a barb Zerker 35 I have gotten well over triple 1200's and with my 23 I gotten 90's, so maybe it is your weapons! I use a Reaver, a 40/40 2hs, I also get near same results with my 2hb, and 2hp. So it has to do with all of what you all saidwould be STR, Dex, Weapon skill, Attack, and Weapon Dmg.