I've killed her two or three times on different occasions and got the ring twice: sold the first one in the bazaar, keeping the second one for my druid alt. Maybe I've just been lucky with the random number generator for once!
Every time so far I and my group have killed her, she drops Unberbulk Bile...this ring is NOT a "common" drop. BTW, we killed her at least 10 to 15 times.
The first 8 times I killed Crinthia, I got the underbulk bile. The next 8 times saw her drop the ring at least 6 times. I spent two days killing everything in the mutant caves and this ring is not as rare as Roy's ring, but it is more common than Torin's horn and Murph's pick.
If it wasn't for the faction hit, I'd slaughter more Preistess Taralofs (misspelled as "Tarafol" on this site) to see if she'd drop the freaking Insignia. Killed her twice and got two ghetto earings, but she went from indifferent to glowering. She still blue to me at level 40. Dang it hurts not to hunt her wussy *** down. Sometimes, even a noble knight wants to be an Iksar scum just for a few minutes.
Edited, Sun Feb 10 23:17:41 2002
____________________________
Duke Ardnahoy Noble Lord Protector of the 70th Crusade Fennin Ro - EQ I
Ardnahoy II Fearless Guardian of the 40th Tour Mistmore - EQ II
Common is the default setting until rarity has been determined... it doesn't necessarily mean that the item is common. This used to get me on a few items too :). Trisha Nytengale 56 Cleric Povar
You are SO right. I have killed her now more then 20 times and she hasn't dropped this ring once. Rare = maybe, Very rare = yes, common = your smokin something and should share. That's my 2cp.
I've killed her probably about 10 times and gotten 5 rings... so I guess it's not the fact of it being common or uncommon, but just luck... now, if only I could get that luck to work out on really good items...