Girplan Hammer of Carnage is better. Girplan Hammer ratio with a 5 dmg aug is 2.64 and you can use the much easier to get Bloodied Shard of Kel`Novar from Struggles Within the Progeny LDON. Bone Staff of Wickedness with a 5 damage aug ratio is 2.56, and the only 5 dmg aug you can put in it is the one from Tunat`Murm in Tacvi. Bone Staff proc does 200 damage, Girplan Hammer proc does 175 damage, but do the math. They both have normal proc rate, 2 ppm, so with max Weapon Affinity and max Combat Effects from heroic dex, you get 5 procs per minute on both of them. doing 25 extra damage 5 times per minute = 25 * 5 / 60 = 2 DPS increase from the proc, your auto attacks with Girplan Hammer will more than make up that 2 DPS.
Edited, Sep 3rd 2023 5:41pm by riguild