On the Karana server, and talking about getting the fish from Frostbite. I am always doing the Stein of Mogguk quest and that quest also requires the fish. I strongly recommend doing the tonic to get the fish from Frostbite. It is just a lot easier, and you don't have any worries.
Okies now to the topic of the quest for the Rodcet Nife. I have tried this, but Arggghh, I hate wasting my fish for this ring because it keeps saying my faction is not good enough. I refuse to do this quest again until my faction is high enough to do it, for heck hehe, I sell my Stein for about 200pp and hate to waste my time on this ring when my faction is not good enough. My suggestion will be to work on the faction before even attempting to do this quest otherwise plan on being frustrated.
Edited, Fri Dec 27 20:27:46 2002