I'd have to have more say than just one person to risk turn in of the Soul Essence. Considering how rare it is to even see drop.. and be the one given it.. i'd want a lead GM to verify that amiable is good enough and actually have them on the spot in case it went wrong.. and i'd still want an email from them saying that not only amiable is good enough, but stating that they'd replace the SE if it didnt work. Not that i lack trust .. but I'm not about to turn to my guildies and say i lost it because i was too dammed impatient to do the quest right after they allowed me such an opportunity.
Ashleighh Dhark
Obsidian Coven
Cazic Thule