Well, first off, you'll use a weapon and shield at frist, because you cannot dual wield until level 13. However, once you get dual wield, you'll want to use a 2nd weapon, because quite a bit of your aggro will come from DPS. A weapon creates considerably more dps than bashing with a shield. In the high end of the game, hate procs start to come into play, but at the low end, there are no real useful procs, especially in original expansion weapons.
If this were truly an oldschool server, you'd start off your armor by smithing some banded, or looting some ringmail. However, to my understanding, the newbie armor quests will still be there on Combine, so do those. That armor is much better than anything that was available back in the day.
You'll probably want to try to get people interested in Runnyeye, once they get up to level 25ish or so, because the blackened alloy weapons in there, are MUCH better than anything that was available when EQ first came out. BA longsword is great for aggro, when the rest of the group has Antonica quality weapons as well.
Also, remember while you are levelling, keep any tradeskill items, and fill your empty slots with anything, even if it's patchwork leather made from ruined bear pelts.
Large bronze armor drops in Najena, and from there, look into the crafted armor quests.
Edited, Thu Jun 1 22:08:21 2006 by xaanru