I petitioned and got this respone:
Hail Ellmadar,
Thank you for contacting Sony Online Entertainment. This is GM Anundr reporting for duty!
I understand that you are trying to make the Enchant Planar Alloy for your husband and you say it is broken. I was more than happy to look into this for you today. After testing this in-game, I was able to create both the Ability: Enchant Planar Alloy and Ability: Mass Enchant Planar Alloy. Not only that, but I was able to learn them on my character. As a result, it looks like everything is working as intended. It is possible that you are not using the correct materials for the combine. Unfortunately, I cannot tell you what the correct components are because that would be considered game hints. I can only suggest that you speak with your fellow players in an attempt to find the correct components. I hope this helps and I wish you the best of luck!
For your convenience, I will leave this ticket open for the next 72 hours. If you have any other questions or concerns pertaining to this situation please feel free to update this petition within the given time frame and I will be more than happy to help out!
Good Day,
GM Anundr
For what it is worth I have done many combos and still nada on my part