Unfortunately it seems like this title is locked to the Prophecy of Ro expansion, even though he is up in zone on the Mangler TLP server (currently in Classic). I am max ally to FP Militia (could not possibly get any better) but Reidar Elsai only cons indifferent to me. When hailed he does give the correct Ally faction response, but no title appears in the title window.
[Sat May 11 01:18:43 2019] Militia Patrol Captain regards you as an ally -- looks like quite a gamble. (Lvl: 50)
[Sat May 11 01:23:37 2019] Reidar Elsai regards you indifferently -- what would you like your tombstone to say? (Lvl: 70)
[Sat May 11 01:23:39 2019] You say, 'Hail, Reidar Elsai'
[Sat May 11 01:23:39 2019] Reidar Elsai says, 'Well, I'll be! You have achieved what most dare not. It takes a particular type of personality to sink so... Er... Show that much dedication to the Freeport Militia's cause. Sir Lucan D'lere has authorized me to offer you a reward for your efforts. Wear this title with... pride I guess.'
[Sat May 11 01:36:08 2019] Guard Sheg regards you as an ally -- looks like quite a gamble. (Lvl: 50)
[Sat May 11 01:36:11 2019] Guard Doolin regards you as an ally -- looks like quite a gamble. (Lvl: 50)
I'm assuming once PoR is unlocked on the server, hailing him would grant the reward title.
Edited, May 11th 2019 12:37am by Zaztik