I set out to do this quest on the Oakwynd TLP server in the PoP / LoY era. I completed my Initiate's Brooch quest as well as the quest for the Soldier's Brooch of the Virtuous (these were for a Froglok Paladin).
I came to High Seer Flogk, hailed him, and he didn't respond at all. Not even saying the key word on this post made him give me any sort of response. But I figured I'd set out to go see if those ground spawns existed anyway, and each one did: Sro, Innothule, and Upper Guk. I collected the 3 and then headed back to Flogk and turned them in, and he responded with
[Mon Jan 15 01:08:06 2024] High Seer Flogk says, 'High Seer Flogk says 'Excellent, you have found all of the items that I need to make the soulstone!' as he goes to work in crafting the items together. 'Allright, there you are, now, what you need to do is take this item, and you Initiates Brooch, and fire it in an oven. This will finish the soulstone, and give you the identification stone that we will use to keep track of you. Good luck, young soldier!'
And handed me the Unfinished Soulstone.
So, the quest appears to work just fine in this era, even though hailing High Seer Flogk and using any keywords do not give any dialogue. Off to go see if I can do the combine!
Oakwynd TLP
PoP / LoY Era
15 Jan 2024
Edited, Jan 15th 2024 3:12am by Erekai