Actually he is absolutely right. With the AC on this item, it makes a poor chest slot for any melee class, and none would sac the AC on their BP for the haste effect. However as a back slot it has very nice AC and the haste is permanent and will stack with chanter spells and bard songs. But there are far better items out there for the back slot with AC and higher "melee" oriented stats. Lodizal shield comes to mind. Any guild that can kill Zlandicar will have similar or better gear then this. In my opinion, as a back slot, this is best suited for Hybrids because of the int, wis, mana and HP addition, as well as haste. 2nd best use is true caster for the same reasons mentioned above. And finally melee and tank for the decent AC and HP/haste. of course the resistances are good for anyone. Thats my opinon and im sticking to it.
btw, my epic (necromancer) is 22/34 1hb. of course id never be in a situation where I was required to melee, but hasted, I could still output decent dmg. Just something to think about before you outright knock a hasted int caster.

