Finally raised my faction and did turn in on 2/10/03. Turned in the hilt, sword, testimony, and letter to Brother Hayle.
HE THEN RETURNED EVERTHING TO ME SANS THE NOTE AND GAVE ME THE NOTE FOR SOULFIRE!!!!!
Turned around, gave him note, and he gave me Soulfire in return.
SO, I know have Soulfire, and still have 3 of the 4 pieces needed to do quest again when the CH charges are gone!!
This blade is sweet, simply for the CH. Basically like having 5 more LoH available to me!!!