I've been trying to get some windstones to drop for the last several hours, and have yet to see a single one. Im posting to vent, and to mention where NOT to try farming for them:
Grieg's End
Scarlet Desert
Twilight Sea
I think I'll head to the tunnels as mentioned by the previous poster...
____________________________
EQ- Bristlebane Vethiss the Elf Slayer 85 +1910 Human Shadowknight Text EQ- Stromm (Luclin-Stromm) Caelith Deepglade 90 +4435 Human Ranger <Inverse Logic>retired
Having spent an evening travelling around Luclin chasing windstones down, I have found a superb spot for them: the tunnels in Grimling Forest that lead to acrylia caverns.
As an 80 ranger I'd basically tag about 20 mobs, AE/melee them down, loot and continue. At that rate I probably made 1 or 2 windstones per pull. The tunnels are constantly repopping, and the side loots (gems and runes) made me several kpp to vendor. With grimling forest having a vendor and a banker, this is just a wonderful place to farm them.
Have been doing research into the drop rates of these little suckers, will post info as i get it.
Griegs end: Yes, they do drop here, off several types of mob (more data to come) The Twilight Sea: Spent several hours killing all types of elemental and not a single windstone-essence of wind still drops from the air elementals tho =) Grimling Forest: Another zone spent several hours and no drop. Acrylia Caverns: None dropped in easy part of zone for me in over 50 hours of murder, not done much in hard zone yet. The Tenebrous Mountains: So far only killed a few, but at the rate the cral Ligi's spawn, its not a viable zone anyway
I have to agree with Loradan. I have been camping grimlings in TB for an hour and a half an no windstones. Either really rare or doesn't drop here anymore. In that tie i killed like 115ish grimlings.
windstones are kinda rare in tenebrous mountains. i'd usually get one windstone on avg every other time i cleared one of the caves. i think they are a little more common in grimling forest, but i have yet to test that out. couple levels my necro will be farming/leveling there, so i'll post something here when i find out something.
____________________________
Razin Firefury 80 Grand Arcanist of Solusek Ro Bertoxxulous Server - Dragon Council speedbump1980@gmail.com
OK...I've been clearing grimlings and aliens in TB for 4 hours now without any Windstone drops. Did SoE kill the drop table for this??? Anyone else notice a problem getting these? I finally got my smithing up to 192 and wanted to start making some acrylia armor, but I can't seem to find the components any more. If anyone has seen some, please let me know. I can't even find them in the bazaar :/.
edit******
OK...ran to GF and started killing the mobs listed above in the caves leading to AC. Got a stack of windstones in about 3 hours of slaughter. It seems like they drop off of almost every mob there, not just the ones listed.
Ppl talk about getting 2 or four in an evening. I got about 40 in a few hours time. See below (below is my own repost) If you are after smithing ingredients and need a ton (literally) of arcrylia ore; then the place for you are the two grimling mining caves in Tenebrous Mtns. I just solo there and go back and forth from cave to cave. They repop in about the same time it takes me to clear both caves, so its pretty much non-stop farming. One good thing is that not only do they drop all the different sizes of acrylia ore, but they drop windstones about as often as the ore pieces/bricks/blocks. I quickly gathered up two stacks of windstones and got about 40 of the ores at the same time. Be sure to go there with empty bags or have good faction with town one zone over because you will also be getting tonz of those silly useless runes that sell for PP and lots of different Luclin vendor-type gems. Not to mention if you are after words/runes for spell making your bags will be filled up after like two rounds of clearing the caves. I hate having to leave a place once I have established a good farm spot, so I often 2-box another toon there to hold junk. There is no way you can get by without destorying hundreds of thier shiny (finesteel) wpn drops. Since they dont stack your bags will be full before one clearing if you wanted to loot them all. As far as smithing goes, you still need the wind essence to make the temper. I have found that it is a royal pain to try to get them from Tenebrous mtns. So many mobs roam and atk you that drop nothing you need that you spend most of your time clearing useless mobs. Then, when you do kill the ones you want (aliens) the drop rate on essences is very low. The same time I spent on farming ore and windstones when I got 80 of those, I spent also on essence and got 5. So your plan should be to head to Twilight sea to get essences. You can slaughter more and faster there and loot other needed stuff while you are at it.
I got 9 of these soloing in GE in about one hour. They didn't seem to drop from any one mob. I just circle from Zone In to the center hall and back. I will have to go back there and try to get screen shot or something to send in info that they do indeed drop in GE and seem more common there than the other zones listed.
I have seen several drop off various rockhoppers in dawnshroud peaks. Didn't read to see if others have said this but wasn't at the dropped from spot so I thought I would add my 2 cp worth.
Got one off my first kill in Umbral Plains this morning from a "disturbed elysian remains", along with my Elysian Boots. Stackable, 0.1 Wt, tiny size, vendor buying price of 16.19 pp, "This item can be used in tradeskills."
I was ML for a guild raid in GE tonight and looted two of these puppies. Didn't think to note what dropped them, pace was a bit quick, but we were not too far in when they dropped.
Was hunting in GF by the AC zone in with a shammy buddy of mine this evening. Had 2 stones drop in a couple of hours off of random grimlings. Mostley we were killing Protectors and Fleshweavers. I dont recall killing any guards. Hope it helps.
The way to go is to buy the windstones. Go to seb if you can solo and make about 7k in 4 hours. Lets see for 7k at 200 a windstone can get 35 windstones. Thats not bad for 4 hours work and at lvl 65 u can get descent aa exp in seb.
I get most of mine in twilight sea off Earth Elementals...I have yet to see a windstone on any of the other three elementals...IE Water, Fire, Air...I have seen one drop of Terra the named also drops Hardy Pants...Ever so often I get lucky and the bezerker Elemental will spawn while farming windstones he drops fetish of the nimble and every so often fetish of the Agile...I hit a run once and got about 20 windstones and 2 fetish of the agile in a week, I have also seen them drop off Crag Li in tenebrous mountains ...also off grimlings but seem to be even more rare in Tenebrous than in twilight and they are rare enough in twilight...I have yet to see one in Scarlet but a guildmate of mine has confirmed that they do drop there but could not remember off what mob...hope this helps...and on my server 200p is generally the going rate, and when you figure it takes two to make the temper I recommend farming your own...
I have killed thousands of earth elementals and have gotten lots of Iron Oxide and drops of mercury as well as some nice little bits and pieces off of greater earth elementals, but I have NEVER seen even one windstone drop from them. I kill earth elementals when I'm farming air elementals for Essence of Wind, and have not seen a single windstone drop. I get windstones without too much competition from the Grimling caves in Tenebrous Mountains.
the Cral Ligi in Tenebrous DO drop windstones, however all of the "named" ones, i.e. Cral Ligi Torchbearer, Cral Ligi Stormwarder, those types ONLY drop the twighlight sea armor quest component, i have never seen any Cral Ligi aside from the Soldiers, and warlords (in tenebrous) drop windstones.
Let see, a bunch of post off a bunch of different servers argueing over what they are worth. How silly. There worth what you can get for them. On my server there are none for sale in bazaar and haven't been for two weeks. I have sold over 80 of them for 200 plat each. You may hold them for a week at that price and all of a sudden someone will come along and buy 20 at one time. Free market economy folks, remember. Personaly, I charge 200 ea cause thats a fair price to me considering the drop rate on them, and they get bought, and I buy up every single one that shows up in bazaar for 150 plat or less, because they sell too. Before you make a wild judgement about whats worth what and who's willing to pay what, check the bazaar and see how many there are on your server first. If there are none, or few, give the 200 plat min a try for a week and I would bet 10 bucks against a donut that whatever you got in stones is gone in a week max.
Totally agreed , the markets on each server are so uncomparable. On Kane Bayle these go for anywhere between 250 and 500 pp each . I personally sell mine for 300 pp each in bazaar and they go in a matter of minutes after setting up trader.
Well, I got about 30 of them stacked up so far for when I do start smithing Acrylia. Smithing now 182 and going to max out plate BP at 188 before I use the hard to get ingredients for Acrylia. Oh, where did I get them is what everyone would like to know. Muhahahaha, yes, wouldn't you? Ah, just kidding. Heres what I do. I am a 58 Necro main and every night around midnight I head to twilight and I hunt, make that slaughter, the entire elemental isle until about 8 am, when people start coming into the zone. The windstones drop mainly off the Terra's, but sometimes off the others also. I average maybe 3 or 4 windstones in 8 hours of solid killing spree where I take out the whole island every 15 spawn cycle. So figure about 60 elemental kills an hour for 8 hours is 480 elemetals to get 3 or 4 stones. Some nights I get maybe 1 and one night I got 7 stones. But I also get an average of about 40 essence of wind, 30 Swirling Mist, 20 drops of mercury, and a number of other nice items. I have killed Aero 3 times and gotten 3 lesser guards of haste, worth about 5K. I killed Terra twice and got Hardy pants, (100 plat crap). I killed Hydro twice and the drop was so bad I can't remember. I did Inferno once and got a flameing short sword, sold for 200 plat. And then the whole mess of lower end fetish and amulet drops off the other Huge, Great, Berzerk, Swift, Giant, ones, along with a few nice higher items worth a couple of K each. So where are the wind stones? Elemental Isle. Are they hard to get? Well, I would say yes they are, unless your a killing machine that can wipe the whole island every cycle for 8 hours straight and do it night after night after night and you consider the windstone drop as a incidental side benefit. Well, thats more then enough wind about wind stones.
I have farmed windstones to make the temper for Acrylia armor for a couple months now. I have personally seen them drop off the Aliens and Grimlings in Tenebrous Mtns. I have cleared the island of elementals many times and believed the windstone was a myth there but actually had one drop last night. 1 in at least 400 elementals. Dropped off a Fire elemental. On Vallon 100pp seems to be the going rate. I refuse to pay more and other smiths I have talked to have stated the same. As for the drop rate in the Grimling Caves of Tene Mnts. 1 in 50 is about right for the drop rate. Actually had 2 drop on the same kill once ( about fell over )
I've farmed about 25 windstones. They do drop off earth elementals and grol baku (brown) in Twilight Sea. Both drop drops of mercury also. I usually get between 2 to 4 a night and sell for 300 - 400. Hope theis helps.
Windstones are used to make powdered windstones. (2 windstones combined in a pestle = 1 powered windstone.) This is used to make Combine Temper (1 powered windstone + 1 essense of wind + 1 vial of clear mana = combine temper). Combine Temper is used to forge Acrylia armors (go to EQTraders.com and look it up yourself.). Acrylia armor is fairly nice stuff, and a good rout to take towards becomming a grandmaster smith. Unfortunatly, two of the ingredients are rare drops (essense of wind and windstone). Truely unfortunate is the fact that you need 2 windstone for every essence. So, where do you get these windstones? My current sources say Craig Li (the blue/air aliens) in Tenebous Mountains, and Grimlings (any) in Tenebous Mountains. So far, it appears that grimlings in other zones don't drop windstone. Also, if anyone can confirm that twilight elementals drop windstone I'd appreciate it. I've cleared the island 3 times and have not gotten a single one (have gotten all old world drops, plus essence of wind/fire, reserch components, and spiny weapons.) Currently, you can occasionaly find 1 on a vendor in Katta for about 21pp, or go to the bazaar (in Fennin Ro) and pick one up for around 100pp. I don't expect the price of these to go up any further because the armor only sells for 1.5-2k (depending on the peice. BP goes for around 2k, but not enough for sale to determin a stable price.).
Awhile ago when I was farming acrylia in the grimling caves. I was inside one cave and me a few friends where seeing these drop. Beleive they were dropping about 1 out of 25 kills or so..had other various stones drop as well as these.
Over the course of the last 19 levels, which I have spent primarily in Tenebrous Mountains, I have slain thousands of Grimlings, so I can state with confidence that the drop rate of Windstones doesn't even approach 4% (1 per 25 Grimings); I have spent quite a few entire evenings without seeing even a single Windstone.
I saw one drop off the Gantru in Umbral Plains today. I kept it for a guildie who needs it for smithing. Seems to be a very rare drops, kind of reminds of the Iksar Blood. That stuff hardly drops either.
Not sure what server you play on, but anyone pricing them at 200pp on Rodcet nife, would be laughed out of the bazaar. 100pp is max, if you want to sell them. there is one goofball who has been trying to sell a windstone for a week+ for 300pp. NOT going to happen. You need TWO windstones, plus an essence of wind, and a clear mana, just to make ONE acrylia temper.
This item is used to make Acrylia Temper, which is then used to make Acrylia Chain and Acrylia Plate armor. It is a crime to destroy this important ingrediant to some very fine armor. Check Bazaar for current prices of acrylia armor and u will see why windstones are prized.
Actually they ARE pretty common. I regularly am farming TM for shreiking substances and pop all the little aliens I can find. Usually in a night (4-5 hours) it is not uncommon for me to come out with half a stack.
And when people are willing to lay down 100pp ea for them it makes me quite the happy camper.
____________________________
-Kyel Mourningblade Paladin of Marr Master Smith (188)
If you are 188 smithing...why are you selling them instead of keeping them for yourself for temper?
On Quellious...they are very rare in bazaar..and if they are for sale it is at 300\350pp each....which i would never pay...I do pay 200pp or cheaper and save em to a stack..then i do acylia smithing run...myself and friends far the ore...I farm them in TM and if i leave with half dozen... I am very happy.